white and black wooden house near green trees during daytime
Credit: Photo by Roger Starnes Sr on Unsplash | Source
Overview

First Encounter Beach, MA Homes for Sale

First Encounter Beach, Eastham, MA, is a scenic and historic community nestled on Cape Cod’s bay side. Known for its tranquil ambiance and stunning natural beauty, this neighborhood offers residents easy access to picturesque beaches, charming local parks, and a peaceful coastal lifestyle. Situated near the historic First Encounter Site, where the Pilgrims first met the Native Wampanoag people, the area combines natural splendor with a rich historical legacy. Homebuyers in this community enjoy a unique combination of historic charm and modern convenience, with a range of properties from cozy beach cottages to more expansive waterfront estates. The peaceful, small-town vibe of Eastham, combined with its proximity to vibrant nearby towns like Orleans and Wellfleet, makes it an appealing place for those looking for serenity and connection to Cape Cod’s storied past.

The beach itself is the star of the community, offering residents and visitors alike a place for swimming, boating, and simply unwinding by the water. First Encounter Beach Eastham is perfect for those who love outdoor recreation or want a place where they can retreat and relax. The homes in this area are diverse, ranging from historic cottages to modern homes, making it an ideal location for different lifestyles and family needs. Whether you’re drawn to the area’s historical significance, its stunning natural surroundings, or its welcoming community, First Encounter Beach Cape Cod offers a peaceful and beautiful place to call home.

Scenic Beachfront Living: Living at First Encounter Beach MA means waking up to beautiful views of Cape Cod Bay. The beach is perfect for a morning walk or watching the stunning sunsets in the evening. Homeowners here enjoy direct access to the beach, providing endless opportunities for swimming, kayaking, or simply relaxing by the water.

A Rich Historical Community: First Encounter Beach holds a significant place in American history as the site of the first meeting between the Pilgrims and the Native Wampanoag tribe. The historical aspect of the area enhances the sense of community and pride in this quaint part of Eastham. Living here not only places you in a scenic location but also in a historically rich community that celebrates its past.

Proximity to Local Amenities: Eastham is a peaceful town, but it’s also conveniently close to other popular Cape Cod locations like Orleans and Wellfleet. Whether you’re looking to enjoy fine dining, shop at local markets, or take in the cultural sights, you’re just a short drive away from a variety of attractions. This balance of serenity and accessibility makes First Encounter Beach an ideal place for those who want the best of both worlds.

Market Overview

Eastham, MA Real Estate Information

Median Listing Price

$833,000

Median Price Per Sq Ft

$579

Average Days on Market

89

Median Price of Sold Homes

$785,000

Home Ownership Percentage

88%

Median Rent

$2,900

Homes in First Encounter Beach

First Encounter Beach, Eastham, MA Real Estate Snapshot

  • Price Range: Homes range from $400,000 for smaller properties to over $2,000,000 for luxury waterfront estates.
  • Typical Year Built: Homes in this area are typically built between the 1960s and 2000s, though some newer properties are available.
  • Typical Interior Square Footage: The majority of homes in the area range from 1,200 to 3,500 square feet, offering both cozy cottages and larger homes.
  • Typical Lot Size: Lots range from 0.2 to 1 acre, providing space for both intimate homes and larger estates with gardens or outdoor recreational areas.
  • Market Facts: Homes generally spend 30-90 days on the market. The average price per square foot is around $350, with many homes featuring traditional Cape Cod architectural styles and updated interiors.
On the map

First Encounter Beach, Eastham, MA Map

To reach First Encounter Beach Eastham, take Route 6 east through Eastham. After passing the Eastham Superette, turn right onto First Encounter Road. Follow the road to the beach parking lot. It’s just a short drive from the center of town, making it easy to access from most parts of Cape Cod.

A professional photo of Erin Terkelsen
Take the next step

Ready to take the next step?

Anchored in Mashpee, where I live with my family, human and canine, my approach to real estate is informed by a passion for Cape Cod’s natural resources. Serving on Mashpee’s Conservation and Sewer Commissions, I bring unique perspective and resources to each transaction. Though born and raised in Pelham, New York, I draw on personal Cape experience and decades of family knowledge. My great grandparents first purchased on the Cape in the spring of 1926. Before becoming a Realtor® I worked for twenty-five years in the culinary industry, finishing my career as Executive Chef at a Boston law firm. With a proven record of client satisfaction, I can navigate complex matters with ease and equanimity. Approachable, funny, and warm, I facilitate my clients’ focus and help them find what matters most.

Meet the locals

Who Lives in Eastham, MA

Population

5,674

Median Age

59

Median Household Income

$72,992

Households

2,860

Household size

2.2

Cost of living

131.5

Entertainment

Things to do Around First Encounter Beach

Eastham Windmill

A charming historical landmark and park.

Salt Pond Visitor Center

Offers trails, exhibits, and local wildlife views.

Cape Cod Rail Trail

A scenic bike trail stretching across the Cape.

Wellfleet Bay Wildlife Sanctuary

Explore walking trails and wildlife exhibits.

Education

Schools near First Encounter Beach

School NameGradesAdmission
Eastham Elementary SchoolPreK - 5Public
Nauset Regional Middle School6 - 8Public
Nauset Regional High School9 - 12Public
Cape Cod Lighthouse Charter SchoolK - 8Charter
Around First Encounter Beach, Eastham, MA

People who like First Encounter Beach also like