Homes for Sale in Cotuit, Barnstable, MA
Cotuit is the smallest village in southwestern Barnstable, surrounded by water on three sides.
It was primarily an agricultural area, then evolved when large-scale seafaring activities flourished along the south coast of The Cape. This boom brought sea captains and businesses, leading to the construction of elegant Greek Revival and Italianate houses that still line the main street today. Many have been exceptionally renovated and serve as private residences. The northwestern corner of the community houses several notable buildings, including the Crocker House, the Cahoon Museum of Art, and other colonial-era houses, adding to the district’s rich heritage.
WATERFRONT LUXURY: Exceptional homes dot the western banks of Cotuit Bay, many with private deepwater docks. Don’t worry if you don’t have one, as there is a boat ramp at Old Shore Road near Ropes Beach. On the opposite side are residences with access to Shoestring Bay and Crocker’s Neck Conservation. The latter spans 97 acres of pristine land with scenic hiking trails, meandering through coastal banks, pine groves, and wetlands. An observation deck overlooks Popponesset Bay, providing breathtaking water vistas. This waterfront setting and natural protected area ensure a life of luxury, serenity, and leisure unique to Cape Cod.
OYSTER PARADISE: Once hailed as the “Oyster Capital of the World,” Cotuit remains renowned for its delectable seafood. It produces a distinct variety of eastern oyster species, famed for their bright and briny flavor. Some say it’s because fresh water from the land meets salty water from the Atlantic Ocean. And since they are exclusive to Cotuit Bay, they have become a sought-after delicacy, gracing the menus of numerous fine-dining establishments across Cape Cod, Boston, and even the world-famous Oyster Bar Restaurant in Grand Central Terminal, New York City. This unique treasure continues to be a point of pride for locals and a highlight for visitors.
VIBRANT COMMUNITY EVENTS: Cotuit buzzes with activity with various engaging events. The crafts fairs allow talented artisans to showcase their creations. The annual Cahoon Museum “Brush Off” is a highly anticipated event where paintings by local artists are auctioned off. The Cotuit Mosquito Yacht Club (CMYC) hosts thrilling yacht races every summer. From gaff-rigged skiffs to junior regattas, the CMYC has fostered a tradition of competitive sailing that spans generations. Sports enthusiasts will love the Cotuit Kettleers, an amateur collegiate baseball team competing in the Cape Cod Baseball League. Fans flock to Lowell Park to witness exciting matchups and support players on the diamond.
Barnstable, MA Real Estate Information
$1,800,000
$495
26
$1,000,000
75%
$2,450
5 Real Estate Facts About Cotuit Homes for Sale
- The community’s real estate landscape is a mix of old and new. Cotuit, MA, homes were constructed from around 1870 to as recently as 2023.
- Cotuit’s architectural style predominantly showcases the elegant Queen Anne and Colonial Revival styles. The Cotuit Library, dating back to 1910, is the only Classical Revival building in the village.
- Cotuit, MA, houses for sale range from $695,000 to $6.5M. Living spaces span from 1,500 to 4,500 square feet.
- Cotuit, MA, homes for sale sit on lots measuring 0.27 to 1.61 acres, allowing spacious outdoor areas.
- Cotuit, MA, real estate also includes vacant land parcels for custom development or investment. Past sales were recorded at $330,000 to $8.15M for lots ranging from 1.3 to 14 acres.
Cotuit Homes for Sale
Cotuit, Barnstable, MA Map
Cotuit is bordered by the Santuit River on the western side, marking the Mashpee town line. To the north, it is adjacent to the village of Marstons Mills, while Osterville lies to the east. The southern boundary of Cotuit meets the scenic Nantucket Sound.
Ready to take the next step?
Anchored in Mashpee, where I live with my family, human and canine, my approach to real estate is informed by a passion for Cape Cod’s natural resources. Serving on Mashpee’s Conservation and Sewer Commissions, I bring unique perspective and resources to each transaction. Though born and raised in Pelham, New York, I draw on personal Cape experience and decades of family knowledge. My great grandparents first purchased on the Cape in the spring of 1926. Before becoming a Realtor® I worked for twenty-five years in the culinary industry, finishing my career as Executive Chef at a Boston law firm. With a proven record of client satisfaction, I can navigate complex matters with ease and equanimity. Approachable, funny, and warm, I facilitate my clients’ focus and help them find what matters most.
Who Lives in Barnstable, MA
50,168
47.1
$123,887
19,574
2.47
131.5
Things to do Around Cotuit
Cotuit Highground Golf Club
This nine-hole course features a rolling terrain and seasonal sea breezes that bring a unique touch to your game.
Cotuit Center for the Arts
You can join visual arts classes, dance workshops, and music sessions or watch theater performances, live music, and comedy shows.
The Loop Beach
Relax with its scenic views of Nantucket Sound and ample space for swimming and sunbathing.
Kettle Ho Cotuit
It is a famous local tavern that serves as a gathering spot for residents to socialize and unwind.
Schools near Cotuit
| School Name | Grades | Admission |
|---|---|---|
| West Villages Elementary | K - 3 | Public |
| Barnstable Intermediate School | 6 - 7 | Public |
| Barnstable High School | 8 - 12 | Public |
| Bayberry Christian School | K - 8 | Private |
| Cape Cod Academy | K - 12 | Private |
| Trinity Christian Academy of Cape Cod | K - 12 | Private |
